|
WSC 2003 Final Abstracts |
Applications in Logistics, Transportation, and Distribution Track
Monday 10:30:00 AM 12:00:00 PM
Strategy Simulations
Chair:
Knud Erik Wichmann (PA Consulting Group)
Tutorial on Business and Market Modeling to Aid
Strategic Decision Making: System Dynamics in Perspective and Selecting
Appropriate Analysis Approaches
Donna D. Mayo and Knud Erik
Wichmann (PA Consulting Group)
Abstract:
System dynamics models have been used to address
strategic questions in many hundreds of companies and government agencies
around the world over the past 40 years, including a broad range of
organizations in the transport sector. However, this technique remains less
well known than other approaches among potential client organizations and
within the simulation community. This paper provides a pithy tutorial on the
system dynamics method and the modeling process, uses transport sector case
examples to illustrate how such models have been valuable in practice, and
compares key characteristics of system dynamics to discrete event simulation.
We close with some guidance on factors to consider when selecting an analysis
approach that is appropriate to the problem under study.
Steering Strategic Decisions at London Underground:
Evaluating Management Options with System Dynamics
Donna D. Mayo
and William J. Dalton (PA Consulting Group) and Martin J. Callaghan (London
Underground Ltd.)
Abstract:
System dynamics simulation models provide a powerful
and rigorous means of evaluating management options in dynamically complex
settings such as a metro subway system. This paper explores how a system
dynamics model has been used over several years to address a variety of
management challenges at London Underground. Several short case illustrations
are described to demonstrate how such models are used in practice to aid
strategic decision making, carry out robust business planning, and communicate
effectively with key stakeholders.
Monday 1:30:00 PM 3:00:00 PM
Supply Chain and Distribution Network
Chair: Luis Franzese (Paragon Tecnologia)
Simulation – A Key Tool to Accelerate and Add
Confidence to Postal Network Configuration
Niels Erik Larsen (PA
Consulting Group)
Abstract:
This paper discusses the reasons for why the postal
industry should use discrete event simulation to improve the performance of
postal networks. Simulation will accelerate and add confidence to decision
making. It improves the match between strategy and the applied network
structures, product portfolio, technology etc. A configurable and flexible
Postal Network Planner (PNP simulation tool) is introduced for “End-to-end”
analysis of the postal logistic value chain. It can establish a nation wide
general view of the cause-effect relationships in a complex postal system.
Several real examples from the postal industry show why simulation is a
prerequisite for creation of innovative and improved solutions.
Semiconductor Supply Network
Simulation
Gary W. Godding (Intel Corporation), Hessam S.
Sarjoughian (Arizona State University) and Karl G. Kempf (Intel Corporation)
Abstract:
More efficient and effective control of supply networks
is conservatively worth billions of dollars to the national and world economy.
Developing improved control requires simulation of physical flows of materials
involved and decision policies governing these flows. This paper describes our
initial work on modeling each of these flows as well as simulating their
integration through the synchronized interchange of data. We show the level of
abstraction that is appropriate, formulate and test a representative model,
and describe our findings and conclusions.
Railroad Simulator on Closed
Loop
Luis Augusto Gago Franzese and Marcelo Moretti Fioroni
(Paragon Tecnologia) and Rui Carlos Botter (University of São Paulo)
Abstract:
This paper presents the procedures and results of a
simulation project of a railroad coal transportation system. Locomotives and
wagons are modeled at the system level, as opposed to other work that inserts
trains at start of the line, and removes them on the other side, just to
analyze line utilization and traffic. The case was based on the Estrada de
Ferro Vitória-Minas (EFVM), managed by Companhia Vale do Rio Doce, one of the
biggest iron coal mining companies in the world. The project helped to find
the best train size, the impact of various changes on the physical line, the
influence of failures and accidents, and provided a full customized interface,
with the ability to do many more experiments.
Monday 3:30:00 PM 5:00:00 PM
Supply Chain Management Simulation
Chair: Randy Gibson (Automation Associates)
Modelling a Continuous Process with Discrete
Simulation Techniques and its Application to LNG Supply
Chains
Niels Stchedroff and Russell C. H. Cheng (University of
Southampton)
Abstract:
This paper discusses the problem of modelling an LNG
supply chain efficiently. The production, processing, transportation and
consumption of LNG (Liquid National Gas) and the associated products are a
topic of major interest in the energy industry. While the problem is
apparently continuous, analysis suggests that this problem can be modelled
using discrete, deterministic techniques. A method involving a modification of
the Three Phase discrete technique was used. Analysis of the way in which the
effects of an event spread leads to a method by which excessive recalculation
can be avoided, yielding a model that is computationally very efficient.
A Prototype Object-Oriented Supply Chain
Simulation Framework
Manuel D. Rossetti and Hin-Tat Chan
(University of Arkansas)
Abstract:
In this paper, we discuss the design, development and
testing of a prototype object-oriented framework for performing supply chain
simulations. We define the primary objects required for supply chain
simulations and design how each of these objects are related to each other to
form a supply chain network. We also present how persistence is handled for
instantiating supply chain network simulations from a database. Finally, we
present a small example simulation to validate and illustrate the concepts.
Initializing a Distribution Supply Chain Simulation
with Live Data
Malay A. Dalal (Union Pacific Railroad), Henry Bell
and Mike Denzien (Simulation Dynamics, Inc.) and Michael P. Keller (Insight
Network Logistics)
Abstract:
This paper describes VinLogic, a simulation of a supply
chain network for the distribution of new automobiles. The model is
implemented in Simulation Dynamic’s Supply Chain Builder product. One of the
key features of the model is its integration with a database containing the
status of all vehicle shipments-VinVision. The information in the database is
used to distribute vehicles and resources through the network at model start,
and the model can then be used to project forward from the current situation.
The model is thus able to have a “warm start,” and does not require the
warm-up period necessary in simulation models that start with the system empty
and idle.
Tuesday 8:30:00 AM 10:00:00 AM
Modeling People Flow
Chair:
Michael Hunter (Georgia Institute of Technology)
Simulation Analysis of International-Departure
Passenger Flows in an Airport Terminal
Soemon Takakuwa (Nagoya
University) and Tomoki Oyama (Recruit Staffing Co., Ltd.)
Abstract:
An entire airport terminal building is simulated to
examine passenger flows, especially international departures. First, times
needed for passengers to be processed in the terminal building are examined.
It is found that the waiting time for check-in accounts for more than 80
percent of the total waiting time of passengers spent in the airport. A
special-purpose data-generator is designed and developed to create
experimental data for executing a simulation. It is found that the possible
number of passengers missing their flights could be drastically reduced by
adding supporting staff to and by making use of first- and business-class
check-in counters for processing economy- and group-class passengers.
Online Simulation of Pedestrian Flow in Public
Buildings
André Hanisch, Juri Tolujew, and Klaus Richter
(Fraunhofer Inst. for Factory Operation & Automation) and Thomas Schulze
(University of Magdeburg)
Abstract:
Online simulation of pedestrian flow in public
buildings is a new tool which can be especially useful for improving the
aspects of safety and short-term planning in the phase of organizing and
operating large public buildings. These might be places such as a train
station, an airport or a shopping center. This paper provides an insight into
the different concepts of pedestrian flow simulation. Special emphasis is
placed on explaining the mesoscopic approach as applied to the area of traffic
simulation. This approach is transferred to the context of analyzing and
predicting the pedestrian flow. A first prototypical implementation of a
simulation supported control center is briefly presented, also.
Development and Validation of a Flexible, Open
Architecture, Transportation Simulation
Michael Hunter (Georgia
Institute of Technology) and Randy Machemehl (The University of Texas at
Austin)
Abstract:
Simulation has been utilized in the planning and
development of almost all sectors of the transportation field. The practicing
transportation community primarily relies on simulation packages, as opposed
to “ground up” simulation development. Unfortunately, the use of these
simulation packages has several disadvantages, most notably the “black box”
phenomenon and reduced modeling flexibility. The simulation approach described
in this paper lays the foundation for a transportation simulation approach
that minimizes the “black box” problem and increases modeling flexibility,
while still providing an easy to use package in which highly capable models
may be quickly and accurately built. This simulation approach utilizes SIMAN
and ARENA. This paper includes a brief discussion of the simulation approach,
a comparison of the proposed simulation and CORSIM results for an intersection
and an arterial, and a comparison of the proposed simulation control delay to
delays collected for a twelve intersection grid north of downtown Chicago.
Tuesday 10:30:00 AM 12:00:00 PM
Simulation of Airports/Aviation
Systems
Chair: Niels Erik Larsen (PA Consulting
Group)
Total Airport and Airspace Model (TAAM)
Parallelization Combining Sequential and Parallel Algorithms for Performance
Enhancement
Neera Sood and Frederick Wieland (The MITRE
Corporation)
Abstract:
This paper describes how to achieve a desired speedup
by careful selection of appropriate algorithms for parallelization. Our target
simulation is the Total Airport and Airspace Model (TAAM), a worldwide
standard for aviation analysis. TAAM is designed as a sequential program, and
we have increased its speed by incorporating multi-threaded algorithms with
minimal changes to the underlying simulation architecture. Our method was to
identify algorithms that are bottlenecks in the computation and that can be
executed concurrently, producing a hybrid sequential and parallel simulation.
Our results show a performance gain that varied between 14% and 33%.
Discrete Event Simulation Model for Airline
Operations: SIMAIR
Loo Hay Lee, Huei Chuen Huang, Chulung Lee, Ek
Peng Chew, Wikrom Jaruphongsa, Yean Yik Yong, Zhe Liang, Chun How Leong, Yen
Ping Tan, and Kalyan Namburi (National University of Singapore) and Ellis
Johnson and Jerry Banks (Georgia Institute of Technology)
Abstract:
SIMAIR is a C++ based research tool meant for the
simulation of airline operations. Various aspects of airline operations like
aircraft, crew and passengers might be simulated to keep the simulation as
close to reality as possible. It provides a means for devising and evaluating
various airline recovery mechanisms to handle disruptions, and can also be
used as a tool to evaluate the performance of a given schedule in operations.
The performance of a given recovery mechanism or a given schedule can be
quantified for research and evaluation purposes.
Simulating Aircraft Delay
Absorption
Justin Boesel (The MITRE Corporation)
Abstract:
An airplane's ability to absorb delay while airborne is
limited and costly. Because of this, the air traffic control system
anticipates and manages excessive demand for scarce shared resources, such as
arrival runways or busy airspace, so that the delay necessary for buffering
can be spread out over a larger distance, or taken on the ground before
departure. It is difficult to model these important dynamics in a standard
queue-resource simulation framework, which does not account for limited delay
absorption capacity. The modeling methodology presented here captures these
dynamics by employing a large number of independent threads of execution to
monitor and enforce a large number of relatively simple mathematical
relationships. These relationships calculate feasible time windows for each
portion of each flight. The model was implemented in the SLX simulation
language. The speed and scalability of SLX are essential to the approach,
which would otherwise be impractical.
Tuesday 1:30:00 PM 3:00:00 PM
Simulation Planning and Rostering
Chair: Frederick Wieland (The MITRE Corporation)
Runway Schedule Determination by Simulation
Optimization
Thomas Curtis Holden and Frederick Wieland (The MITRE
Corporation)
Abstract:
Many airport runway expansion projects are restricted
by space limitations imposed by development in the vicinity of the airport.
This often causes planners to choose configurations for new runways that limit
the use of these runways in time and/or space. Studies that model airports
with new runways that are not yet operational need to develop plausible
operational models for these new runways since historical data is not
available. We look at a runway schedule problem encountered during the
configuration and validation step of an earlier study. We develop a method
using simulation optimization to approach the runway schedule problem and
compare it to a manual approach developed in the earlier study. We use the
Total Airspace and Airport Modeler to model the airport and airspace
operations and Fast Simulated Annealing for the optimization.
A Simulation Approach to Manpower
Planning
Massoud Bazargan-Lari, Payal Gupta, and Seth Young
(Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University)
Abstract:
This paper describes the development of a computerized
line maintenance simulation model for strategic manpower planning at
Continental Airlines for one of their major maintenance stations at Newark
airport. The simulation model provides guidelines to the development of
enhanced staffing models and a better understanding of resource requirements
on a daily basis. The proposed simulation model could be used as a tool to
support the management of the line maintenance department in solving various
capacity planning issues related to the manpower requirement and scheduling.
The recent capabilities of simulation modeling, namely optimization modeling
is adopted in search of enhanced shift schedule of technicians that would
improve the efficiency of the existing system.
A Discrete Event Simulation for the Crew
Assignment Process in North American Freight Railroads
Rainer
Guttkuhn, Todd Dawson, and Udo Trutschel (Circadian Technologies, Inc.) and
Jon Walker and Mike Moroz (Canadian National Railroad)
Abstract:
This paper introduces a discrete event simulation for
crew assignments and crew movements as a result of train traffic, labor rules,
government regulations and optional crew schedules. The software is part of a
schedule development system, FRCOS (Freight Rail Optimization System), that
was co-developed by CN Rail and Circadian Technologies, Inc. The simulation
allows verification of the impact of changes to trainflow, labor rules or
government regulations on the overall operational efficiency of how crews are
called to work. The system helps to evaluate changes to current crew
assignments and can test new crew assignment scenarios such as crew schedules.
Potential problems can be detected before the actual implementation, saving
unnecessary costs. The software is also used to assess the impact of traffic
changes on existing crew schedules in order to implement reactive corrections
to these schedules.
Tuesday 3:30:00 PM 5:00:00 PM
Traffic and Road Planning Simulation
Chair: Heinz Weigl (ESLA Solutions)
Simulation of Freeway Merging and Diverging
Behavior
Daiheng Ni (Georgia Institute of Technology) and John D.
Leonard, II (Georgia State Road & Tollway Authority)
Abstract:
Simplified theory of kinematic waves was proposed by
Newell and uses cumulative arrival and departure counts to describe kinematic
waves of freeway traffic. The original paper deals only with traffic on
freeway mainline. It is of great interest, at least practically, to
investigate whether the simplified theory can be used to simulate freeway
traffic merging and diverging behavior. In his paper, Newell assumed that
on-ramp traffic always has the priority and can bypass queues, if any. This
assumption will be released so that traffic from the mainline and the on-ramp
will have to compete for downstream supply. For off-ramps, Newell assumed that
all vehicles that want to exit can always be able to do so. Again, this
assumption is also released so that queues from either downstream can build up
and block upstream traffic.
Modeling Ambulance Service of the Austrian Red
Cross
Othmar Koch (Vienna University of Technology) and Heinz Weigl
(ESLA Solutions)
Abstract:
We discuss a simulation model used in the analysis of
the transport logistics of the Austrian Red Cross rescue organization. The
emphasis is on the details of modeling the scheduling of ambulance service in
the simulation environment ARENA. A heuristic (near-) optimal strategy is
employed to coordinate patients' transports, where some parameters with an
intuitive interpretation, which are involved in the decision process, have to
be suitably chosen. The validity of the model is apparent from the
interpretation of the results in terms of the structure of the organization
and coordination of services provided.
Simulation Modelling in Support of Emergency
Fire-Fighting in Norfolk
Alan C. Cowdale (Royal Air Force
Waddington)
Abstract:
In the fall of 2002 the Fire Brigade Union within the
United Kingdom proposed a ballot on strike action in support of a wage demand.
Consequently the Ministry of Defence agreed that in the event of strike
action, emergency assistance to the local authorities would be provided by
deploying military staff to man fire-fighting equipment and to provide command
and control functions. The military Detachment Commander for the County of
Norfolk region was faced with a number of issues regarding basing of assets
and asset management. This paper describes how simple simulation modelling was
used to provide insights into the type of issues that the military would face
in undertaking this role. Two models were developed; one using SIMUL8 to
investigate asset utilisation, and the other using VisualBasic to generate a
master event list for use in mission planning and control centre training.
Wednesday 8:30:00 AM 10:00:00 AM
Freight Simulation
Chair:
Enver Yucesan (INSEAD)
Dynamic Freight Traffic Simulation Providing Real-Time
Information
Jinghua Xu and Kathleen L. Hancock (University of
Massachusetts) and Frank Southworth (Oak Ridge National Laboratory)
Abstract:
The paper describes a prototype Dynamic Freight Traffic
Simulation model called DyFTS, constructed for studying the effects of highly
developed information technologies and logistic strategies on freight
transportation. DyFTS is designed as a highly adaptable system that can be
easily embedded into a more comprehensive transportation simulation model.
Various decision-making processes are formulated, such as goods-to-vehicle
assignment, departure time choice and pre-trip routing, and en-route vehicle
redirection. As part of the modeling system, descriptive real-time information
for the network is simulated to study the influence of such information on
freight transportation. A knowledge-based learning process is established to
refine the perceptions of decision-makers to the transportation network based
on past experience. Numerical examples are designed to compare a set of
freight movements operating both with and without the aid of real-time
information, as such freight operations vary according to different delivery
time requirements and using different fleet configurations.
The Modal-Shift Transportation Planning Problem and
its Fast Steepest Descent Algorithm
Masami Amano, Takayuki
Yoshizumi, and Hiroyuki Okano (IBM Research)
Abstract:
The Modal-Shift Transportation Planning Problem (MSTPP)
is the problem that finds a feasible schedule for carriers with the minimum
total cost when sets of facilities, delivery orders, and carriers are given.
In this paper, we propose a fast steepest descent algorithm to solve the
MSTPP. Our solution generates a set of candidate routes for each delivery
order as a preprocess. Then, it finds a schedule by iteratively updating
selections of the candidate routes in descent directions, while computing a
configuration of carrier movements at each iteration by a greedy algorithm.
Intensive numerical study using artificial data modeled from the manufacturing
industry in Japan is also presented.
A Monte Carlo Simulation Approach to the
Capacitated Multi-Location Transshipment Problem
Deniz Özdemir and
Enver Yücesan (INSEAD) and Yale T. Herer (Israel Institute of Technology)
Abstract:
We consider a supply chain, which consists of N
retailers and one supplier. The retailers may be coordinated through
replenishment strategies and lateral transshipments, that is, movement of a
product among the locations at the same echelon level. Transshipment
quantities may be limited, however, due to the physical constraints of the
transportation media or due to the reluctance of retailers to completely pool
their stock with other retailers. We introduce a stochastic approximation
algorithm to compute the order-up-to quantities using a sample-path-based
optimization procedure. Given an order-up-to S policy, we determine an optimal
transshipment policy, using an LP/Network flow framework. Such a numerical
approach allows us to study systems with arbitrary complexity.
Wednesday 10:30:00 AM 12:00:00 PM
Waterway, Shipping, and Ports
Chair: William Biles (University of Louisville)
Modeling Ship Arrivals in
Ports
Eelco van Asperen, Rommert Dekker, Mark Polman, and Henk de
Swaan Arons (Erasmus University Rotterdam)
Abstract:
Ports provide jetty facilities for ships to load and
unload their cargo. Since ship delays are costly, terminal operators attempt
to minimize their number and duration. Here, simulation has proved to be a
very suitable tool. However, in port simulation models, the impact of the
arrival process of ships on the model outcomes tends to be underestimated.
This article considers three arrival processes: stock-controlled, equidistant
per ship type, and Poisson. We assess how their deployment in a port
simulation model, based on data from a real case study, affects the efficiency
of the loading and unloading process. Poisson, which is the chosen arrival
process in many client-oriented simulations, actually performs worst in terms
of both ship delays and required storage capacity. Stock-controlled arrivals
perform best with regard to ship delays and required storage capacity.
Optimization of a Barge Transportation System for
Petroleum Delivery
Nicholas P. Anderson, Gerald W. Evans, and
William E. Biles (University of Louisville) and Todd C. Whyte (American
Commercial Barge Lines)
Abstract:
This paper describes a simulation model of a liquid
fuel supplier operating on the Ohio River. Each day, orders arrive for six
different fuel types at six different locations. The goal of this study was to
determine the appropriate number of tow boats required to meet the demand for
fuels. The system was analyzed using Arena and Optquest.
Iterative Optimization and Simulation of Barge
Traffic on an Inland Waterway
Amy Bush, W. E. Biles, and G. W.
DePuy (University of Louisville)
Abstract:
This paper describes an iterative technique between
optimization and simulation models used to determine solutions to optimization
problems and ensure that the solutions are feasible for real world
operations(in terms of a simulation model). The technique allows for the
development of separate optimization and simulation models with varying levels
of detail in each model. The results and parameters of the optimization model
are used as input to the simulation model. The performance measures from the
simulation output are compared to acceptable levels. These performance
measures are then used to modify the optimization model if the simulation
results are not acceptable. This iterative approach continues until an
acceptable solution is reached. This iterative technique is applied to barge
traffic on an inland waterway as an example. Linear programming is used as the
optimization technique for the example while a simulation model is developed
using Arena software.